Plus, the technicians who will be repairing your computer are experts in this field. So although theres overlap, there are unique features only VMAX offers. The hardware upgrades are just point bumps to each product line, but nothing that actually changes the game. Director, software development. NorthSmart can provide support for X2-SD-SWITCH-FD hardware after the end of official support date, saving you money in the process, As a If your products are at the end of their life or support life, you may feel like you are stuck. [6][9], The XtremIO X2 line was introduced in May, 2017. Allowing you to extend the support cycle and maximize the value of your hardware by saving 30 - 40% against that XtremIO contract. Now that we know how important the UPS is to XIO even functioning, that seems a step crazier than necessary, because if youre in the process of replacing one and simply bump the serial cord out of the other, the array will go to fully degraded and shut down. What can be a little confusing is the positioning of Dell EMCs flash storage portfolio. Dell EMC has announced XtremIO X2, the first major update to their mainstream enterprise all flash array in some time. Leaving you to focus on running Exact same issue and your solution worked like a charm. The silver lining is that every forklift is an opportunity for customers to evaluate industry-leading alternatives, such as FlashArray//X. Seriously they should be sued. EMC wake up guys! EMC XtremIO is a storage array enterprise created to work with flash . program for Dell EMC customers who are seeking a modern storage ownership experience. This is an obvious benefit for traditional platforms like databases. However, whether your array is down due to battery failure, or battery lifecycle counter reaching zero, you still have extra ridiculous steps to perform. Although the solution was technically scale-out, it couldnt actually be scaled in the initial release. 4. Call us at 888-8-TOPGUNor fill out ourrequest form and one of our platform experts will call you. X2 systems use an NV-RAM drive and super-capacitor. The EMC Online Support web site maintains a comprehensive list of EMC software products with associated End of Service Life (EOSL) dates. Dell EMC PowerBricks VMAX um, yeah, it's called PowerMax now Article Number: 497394: Article Version: 4: Article Type: How To: XtremIO HW Gen1,XtremIO HW Gen2 400GB,XtremIO HW Gen2 400GB Encrypt Capbl,XtremIO HW Gen2 400GB Encrypt Disable,XtremIO HW Gen2 400GB Exp Encrypt Disable,XtremIO HW Gen2 400GB Expandable,XtremIO HW Gen2 . The SCs must have at least one UPS, reporting a good status, and known firmware, with 70% charge, to one SC, or it will refuse to boot the array up. tagor villas ritz carlton, abama; daredevil main villains xtremio x2 end of life. At a high-level, Dell EMC has refreshed and released two potentially overlapping products, and we applaud them for clarifying what each is for: VMAX for tier 1 workloads and consolidation, and XtremIO for point VDI and snapshot heavy environments like test & development (test/dev). Todd indicated at SFD14 that the biggest use case for XtremIO is supporting traditional databases with large numbers of snapshots. Copyright (c) 2009-2019 Post #6381 Chris M Evans, first published onhttps://www.architecting.it/blog, do not reproduce without permission. Request a quote from our team today. without any errors. So has XtremIO X2 moved on? And, the implicit absence of XIOS 6.0 availability on X1 hardware, and the inability to mix X1 and X2 bricks, is frankly indefensible at this stage. Dell EMC XtremIO is a purpose-built all-flash array that provides consistent high performance with low latency; unmatched storage efficiency with inline, all-the-time data services; rich application integrated copy services; and unprecedented management simplicity. The top reviewer of Dell SC Series writes "The performance was staggering and more than . Retrofit complexity abounds on VMAX All-Flash. In comparison, the Pure FlashArray//M has proven, measured 6 9s across our install base now coming up on two years, and its inclusive of maintenance and upgrades. Subscribe to Pure Perspectives for the latest information and insights to inspire action. XtremIO: Apparently unreliable for Tier 1 workloads. In comparison, the Pure FlashArray//X uses Intel Broadwell CPUs and we have a proven history of introducing newer Intel CPU-based controllers every 12 to 18 months. 800 Battery Ave SE STE 100 optional. EMC certainly needed to get their money back. . They were originally scalable to four X-Bricks, linked by dual InfiniBand, delivering 1 million IOPS. VDI has been mentioned a number of times now as a focus for XtremIO, but what about high-end workloads? Dell EMC XtremIO X2, XtremIO, XtremIO X2. For example, you bought a single X2 X-Brick with 36 drives, you now want to scale UP (a new feature to X2, in X1 you could only scale out and now you can either scale up, out or both), you simply add another 6 drives, the procedure is fully non-disruptive. Software migration packages are simply not equivalent. 106 Prior Lake, MN 55372 888-8-TOPGUN [emailprotected], Copyright 2007-2023 Top Gun Technology | All Rights Reserved |, DS-13SLT-FAB1 (Fab1 module no model assigned), 2640, 3/176, 3/164, 6/176, 9/88 Tape Libraries, Greenplum Data Computing Capacity Appliance, Switch Arista 32-PORT 40GbE Upgrade Leaf (851-0282), Switch Arista 48-PORT 10GbE Upgrade Leaf (851-0283), Switch Arista 64-PORT 40GbE Chassis (851-0261), Switch Arista 96-PORT 10GbE Chassis (851-0260), Switch Celestica 24-PORT 10GbE (851-0258), Switch Celestica 32-PORT 40GbE (851-0259), Switch Celestica 48-PORT 10GbE (851-0257), switch Dell S4112F 12-port 10GbE (851-0334), Switch Dell S4148 48-PORT 10GbE (851-0317), Switch Dell Z9100 32-PORT 40GbE (851-0316), Switch Dell Z9264 64-port 40 GbE (851-0318), Switch MELLANOX 18-PORT QDR IB (851-0168), Switch MELLANOX 18-PORT QDR Upgrade Leaf (851-0311), Switch MELLANOX 36-PORT QDR IB (851-0284), Switch MELLANOX 54-PORT 10U QDR (851-0312), Switch MELLANOX 54-PORT 7U QDR (851-0313), Switch QLOGIC 24-PORT QDR Upgrade Leaf (851-0150), Switch QLOGIC 48-PORT 5U-040 QDR IB (851-0149), Switch QLOGIC 96-PORT 5U-210 QDR IB (851-0151), Switch QLOGIC SILVERSTORM 144-PORT DDR IB Switch, Switch QLOGIC SILVERSTORM 24-PORT DDR IB Switch, Switch QLOGIC SILVERSTORM 48-PORT DDR IB Switch, Switch QLOGIC SILVERSTORM 96-PORT DDR IB Switch, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;12x3.5 DS;12x1200GB 10K, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5DS;11x200GB FAST VP, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5DS;16x200GB FAST VP, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5DS;21x200GB FAST VP, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5DS;10x800GB FAST VP, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5 DS;12x1200GB 10K, VNXe3200;2xSP DPE;25x2.5 DS;25x1200GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;12x3.5 DS;12x2TB 7200K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;12x3.5 DS;12x900GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;12x3.5 DS;12x1200GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;12x3.5 DS;6x1200GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;25x2.5 DS;12x900GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;25x2.5 DS;25x900GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;25x2.5 DS;12x1200GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;25x2.5 DS;25x1200GB 10K, VNXe32;2xSP DPE;DC;25x2.5 DS;6x1200GB 10K, Vblock Specialized System for Extreme Applications, VxBlock System 1000 (PowerMax 2000, 8000), VxBlock System 1000 Unity XT (300/300F/400/400F/500/500F/600/600F OE/380/380F/480/480F/680/680F/880/880F OE/350F/450F/550F/650F OE), VxBlock System 350 Unity AF Gen1 (300F/400F/500F/600F), VxBlock System 350 Unity Hybrid (300/400/500/600), VxBlock System 350 Unity AF Gen-2 (350F/450F/550F/650F). XtremIO Spec Sheet: Details on the New //X In Town - Pure Storage Raghuram Naidu Dadisetty - Solutions Architect - LinkedIn View Dates. [2][10], These differences enabled significant performance gains (80% improvement in response times[11]) but prohibit the coexistence of X1 and X2 hardware in the same cluster. This is now simplified in the two models. This claims to have reduced latency by a factor of 5x. Now do this same process on the second UPS. With the recent termination of DSSD, many had wondered how VMAX (and XtremIO) might possibly leverage Dell EMCs acquired NVMe knowhow and proprietary technology maybe in the future seems to be the response. Dell EMC XtremIO X2 maintenance and support are required 675,714 professionals have used our research since 2012. This is a v1.0 product! The XtremIO X2-R end of life date doesnt mean your all-flash storage array is on its last legs. time-consuming. X2-SD-BASE-ELA. As the global leader in data center and networking optimization, we work with more than 21,000 companies across the globe boosting infrastructure performance and Uptime, maximizing IT staff and stretching budget. But wait, theres more; as shipped between at least 2015-2016, this iteration of XtremIO with Eaton 5p 1550 UPSs is a ticking time bomb, because the UPS has a battery lifetime counter that counts down until zero is reached, and upon reaching zero, goes into a degraded state. Its interesting to note that following a visit from Joe Tucci, two VMware execs visited the company shortly before it was acquired. The best option is to work with TPM. Fill out the form and we'll schedule a meeting with a NorthSmart expert. So, upgrade your failed UPS to the current version, then make use of the battery lifecycle reset option to clear that countdown. As long as there arent any glaring issues with the hardware or problems with its place in your companys infrastructure, you can keep using it for longer by using TPM. XtremIOs CTO has said that [p]eople dont realize, [that] the larger the drive capacity gets, the worse the performance gets and that the XtremIO team was not willing to sacrifice our predictable performance. X2-R avoids the performance density challenge (with support for 1.92TB SSDs only) at the sacrifice of capacity density. Check out this post, in which I discuss XDP changes, specifically in the comments, where the XDP groups are explained. And those differences create a sharp contrast for customers. Home End of Service Life Dell EMC End of Service Life. The architecture appears to be so different that the XIOS 6.0 software may not even work on the previous-generation X1. 4. Thanks EMC! [1] The current version is the X2 line. For X2 S multi brick weight subtract 16Kg (single bricks weigh the same) SPECIFICATION SHEET would you please guide me more on this matter? If you keep your equipment, you will have to go without help from the original equipment manufacturer. IO path on X2 is completely new. With X2, IOs are committed to NV-RAM vs. flash with X1. EMC XTREMIO X2-S INFINIBAND SWITCH EOL Date Not Published EMC XTREMIO X2-S INFINIBAND Touring the world with friends one mile and pub at a time; is heavenly gondola open today. The capacity range for a single X2-S X-Brick is 7.2-28.8 TB, and the capacity range for a single X2-R X-Brick is 34.5-138.2 TB. *Please select an option from the dropdown menu, Primenet | All Rights Reserved | Registered in England and Wales 03139999, Dell EMC XtremIO KYLIN Server 256GB D25-400, Unit 8 Arlington Court, Whittle Way, , Stevenage, 7 Best Practices for Vulnerability Assessment & Management, Everything you need to know about a Data Breach, Why end of service life doesn't mean the end, How to reduce IT infrastructure and operations costs, How IT outsourcing helps to scale your technical team. The improvements in XtremIO are positive and it will be interesting to see where Dell EMC takes the platform next. X2 will lag behind with its use of Haswell CPUs. Hardening storage products is hard, time-consuming work. XtremIO X2. Stay up-to-date on end of life & end of service life with our simple, easy to use database. IT Infrastructure Management How to Stay on Budget & Innovate. End of Service Life and Extended Support information can be found on Overview. Lets get started! FlashArray//X: Details on the New //X In Town - Pure Storage Blog You can find the passwords to both on my page here. to ensure that the system continues to deliver optimum peak performance Compare XtremIO vs. Unity all-flash storage system for VDI And, while we compete and win plenty against VMAX All-Flash, we have yet to see customers turning on VMAX All-Flash compression. xtremio x2 end of life. Dell EMC XtremIO KYLIN Server 256GB D25-400 | Maintenance & EOSL XtremIO uses remote procedure calls (RPC) for control messages and remote direct memory access (RDMA) for moving data blocks. EMC XTREMIO X2-S 400GB 72-SLOT CHASSIS - serviceexpress.com We utilize more than 2000 world class engineers. https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/2105650-eaton-5p-5px-battery-countdown Dell discontinuing support for your equipment doesnt imply it needs to be replaced. NorthSmart has extensive experience in supportingEOL & EOSL EMC equipmentwith best-in-class hardware maintenance services. Each X-Brick consists of two active-active controller nodes and a drive bay. Learn More. Required fields are marked *. Different clusters can be managed within the same IT interface, however.[10]. End of support for XtremIo - Dell Community 99.9999% uptime seems elusive for XtremIO. With end-to-end non-volatile memory express (NVMe), real-time machine learning, seamless cloud mobility, and up to 350GB per . The X2-R uses 1.92TB drives, with capacity from 34.5TB to 138.2TB (1.92TB drives). Recent/Upcoming EOL & EOSL Dates: EMC VNX 5200, 5400, 5600, 5800, 7600, and 8000 go EOSL January 31, 2023. Learn how Top Gun provides the right support to help you keep, fine-tune and maintain your End of Life EMC systems. Gain in-depth understanding of how to leverage and optimize XtremIO features and capabilities in specic application areas. https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/2156361-5p1000-weirdness End of life: 31/08/2018. Dell EMC XtremIO X2 | SANStorageWorks.com An end-of-service-life announcement can spell trouble for IT managers. For example, if you start with X2-S, you scale with X2-S. Getting to X2-R is a forklift upgrade from X2-S. Explore our database of over 20,000 parts & never miss a critical date again. Some of the unique features of the platform include a proprietary RAID implementation (XDP), with only around 8% overhead. Dell EMC XtremIO 4.0. XtremIO X2. Obviously, VMAX supports mainframe (z/Series) and AS400 (i/Series), which XtremIO will never do. By extending the life of your 5. Toll Free: 800-409-3132, 2023 NorthSmart | All Rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service. Thank you !!. Dell EMC is promoting X2-S systems for higher de-duplicating workloads, such as VDI. Running WordPress behind an nginx reverse proxy on a different domain, Fix for EMC XtremIO complete failure due to Eaton BBU / UPS issues, https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/2156361-5p1000-weirdness. Let us extend the life of your hardware and make you a budget hero! You should now have a working UPS that reports as good to the XIO SC. serial to the same XtremIO Storage Controller. X2 is available in two models: X2S (uses 400GB SSDs) and X2R (uses 1.92TB SSDs). The end result is Pure saves you a lot of flash. If you are fixing your computer hardware yourself, you may not have access to the same parts that the manufacturer uses. . Atlanta, Georgia 30339 Similarly, VMAX All-Flash is available in four models: VMAX 250F, 450F, 850F, and 950F (assuming the 450F and 850F are not soon EOLd). However, this has turned out not to be the case. PROCESSING PRACTICE: CPU & SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE, EMC close to buying XtremIO for $400-$450m, Traditional array all-flash retrofits knock XtremIO off top sales rung, Dell EMC Introduces New All-Flash Storage Systems to help Customers Modernize Their Data Centres and Transform IT, Garbage Collection #008 Chris Travels Commvault, NetApp and SFD14, Dell EMC Presents High-End Systems at Storage Field Day 14. Eaton designed this pile of crap rack mount UPS to require removal from the rack to replace the batteries; ROFL. What is XtremIO x2? Replication Configuration If you think youre going to be slick and just bypass the UPSs, you cant. Capacity density at the cost of performance. equipment with our maintenance and IT support, you get a comprehensive But how will you deal with technical difficulties or breakdowns? Model Number. diffstat for arp-scan-1.8.1 arp-scan-1.8.4 ChangeLog | 142 INSTALL | 5 Makefile.in | 621 ++- NEWS | 40 TODO | 46 aclocal.m4 | 357 + arp-fingerprint | 58 arp-scan.1 . Were also working on this same exact project when you mention the battery lifecycle reset option is this something Id see while in SetUPS or in a different management utility? XIOS 6.0 does NOT appear to be backwards compatible to X1. 3. Software and hardware improvements allow XtremIO X2 systems to scale more incrementally than earlier XtremIO systems, allowing both scale-up capacity growth by adding storage to a single X-Brick (new to X2), and scale-out capacity growth by adding additional X-Bricks (possible in earlier configurations). Allowing you to extend the support cycle and maximize the value of your hardware by saving 30 - 40% against that XtremIO contract. An upgrade will still be necessary at some point, but TPM can help delay it. Seriously, with XtremIO (Gen 2 in this case, not sure about future iterations or the XIO2), if you have the misfortune of both of the included standby UPSs experiencing issues simultaneously, your array will shut down and refuse to restart. Dell EMC XtremIO X2 Reviews - Gartner Powered by ServiceNow, Top Gun Technology provides TPM 2.0 maintenance services that are uniquely designed to deliver the highest quality of infrastructure support for mission critical operations. It was an opportunity to catch up on a technology Ive been less than positive about over the years. Need to know EMC XTREMIO X2-S INFINIBAND SWITCH EOL & EOSL Date? You really cant make this fucking shit up. And, with no upgrade path from VMAX 450F/850F models to the VMAX 950F without a hardware and capacity re-buy and data migration, buying a VMAX 450F/850F today is equivalent to firing up the forklift. It also highlights if a model had reached End of Life (EOL) or End of Service Life (EOSL) and identifies if recommended firmware updates are available. EMC VMAX 450F and 850F go EOSL October 31, 2023. The base unit of the XtremIO X2 line is the X-Brick. We touched on this in a recent Storage Unpacked podcast. Dell EMC XtremIO 4.0 - Curvature Learn how Top Gun provides the right support to help you keep, fine-tune and maintain your End of Life EMC systems. VMAX 250F/950F models employ 7.68TB and 15.36TB SSDs, Intel Broadwell CPUs, and 12Gb/s SAS-3 back-end shelves, whereas the VMAX 450F/850F models, which GAd just over a year ago, remain stuck on lower capacity SSDs, older CPUs, and 6Gb/s SAS-2 back-end shelves. PDF XTREMIO X2 SPECIFICATIONS - SANStorageWorks.com XtremIO fills a gap in high-end performance where the VMAX level of resiliency or features isnt required. Its easy to overlook or lose track of EOSL dates. Read Book Mastercam X2 Installation Guide Mastercamthaitraining Com Chris Evans 22 January 2018 All-Flash Storage, Storage Hardware. Our premium service is tailored directly to your needs, In May 2017, Dell EMC announced X2, the next generation of XtremIO. The battery backup unit, previously used to de-stage data from memory in the case of power loss, has been replaced. In our view this is a rational position VMAX where reliability trumps efficiency, and XtremIO where efficiency (via purpose-built data reduction) trumps reliability. Getting rid of the batteries isnt enough. For those interested in checking out our deeper evaluation, please read on. The system is content-aware where the data is laid out uniformly across all SSDs using the unique fingerprint of the incoming data. Dell EMC XtremIO X2 - Curvature This goes back to the VDI discussion XtremIO is price sensitive to the level of data de-duplication that can be achieved. Scaling with Brick-based scale-out is complex and costly. . Youre going to need to upgrade the firmware to version 25 or above to gain the ability to reset the lifecycle counter, and then downgrade back to the version you have, followed by a factory reset. Hardware density was increased; the X2 features more processing cores and a 4U controller head instead of the old 6U profile. Course Description Vibration Analysis is one of the most powerful condition based maintenance technologies, and the cornerstone of many predictive maintenance programs. xtremio x2 end of life - mountaintreasure.vn In the version of firmware that EMC ships these with, you cannot reset the battery lifecycle counter. And, with our Evergreen on-ramp via our new NVMe NOW! If you have any related links of interest, please feel free to add them as a comment for consideration. Liran Loya - Senior Director, Software Engineering - Dell EMC XtremIO 1 Cybersecurity requirements: PowerStoreOS 2.0 or higher. Interested in learning more about how Park Place can help maximize your uptime after the OEM warranty? STORAGE. Individual X-Bricks can scale up by adding as few as two SSDs at a time to any single brick. Should clear the counter either way, then you downgrade back to the .0016 version. Presumably, new customers are already being diverted to X2, so its just a case of maintaining the older legacy X1 systems until customers transition to X2. Dell XtremIO vs HPE StoreOnce Comparison 2023 | PeerSpot X2-T is available May 3rd. However, the reason I say to look for this is because your array will refuse to power on if the Eaton firmware is not the version EMC wants it to be at. new Dell EMC system: configuration, installation, and integration into your existing Toll Free: 800-409-3132, Two Ballpark Center While the VMAX All-Flash models support NVMe-enabled vault drives, these are not in the normal IO path, where NVMe is needed to unlock its real benefits. with your particular business in mind. Solution-oriented IT professional with over 5 years' experience in IT service delivery and management; well versed with up to date best IT practices and standards to ensure an organization's' systems have secure connections and perform efficiently to serve the needs of its employees.<br><br>I am interested in implementation and automation of on premise and cloud solutions to improve . The challenge now is that, in the cloud and digital era, enterprises (rightly) demand performance, reliability, and efficiency, without compromises, and without having to manage two independent silos of storage. Some TPM programs, like NorthSmart, let you choose the services you need and even create a hybrid model with some features of OEM and TPM support. In the cloud era, theres no room for legacy disk protocols like SCSI and SAS. So lots of extra redundancy (like battery backup and dual nodes) was put into each X-Brick configuration. In comparison, FlashArray//X will be 6x denser than both VMAX 950F and X2, and the DirectFlash technology that powers //X means the capacity density is delivered with full performance. Each expansion Brick requires the same number of SSDs. 9560 85th Ave N This will allow you to upgrade at your own pace and when youre ready. VMAX: Inefficient, complex, and expensive. Different Brick models are NOT mixable / upgradable to other Brick models. Oh yes, you know the drill, EMC (now Dell/EMC) never overlooks a chance to create a dependency from a multi-hundred-thousand dollar disk array on a $1000 battery backup, or a $16 lead acid battery for that matter. Your applications are always-on with FlashArray. infrastructure. Our premium service is tailored directly to your needs, with your particular business in mind. Power it back on. Advisories. 11-29-2021 10:27 AM. I used Eaton SetUPS tool. With Pure, they can get all three with the new (Orange) //X. 24/7 coverage includes helpdesk, onsite, call-homemonitoring, and partsreplacement. your business effectively. This will drastically raise maintenance and support rates. Select a Model. The XtremIO X2-R end of life date doesn't mean your all-flash storage array is on its last legs. It took X1 4+ years just to get where it is today, and it looks like the clock is resetting. Signup for our newsletter to get notified about our next ride. Youll want to SSH into it as xmsadmin, and then log in as the tech user. This, Dell claims, lowers replication bandwidth needs by up to 75 per cent over rival replicators that transmit all the data in a changed file. If you dont have a lot of extra money to spend on upgrades, you can still use your existing hardware with the help of TPM. Compression is not always-on; it must be configured manually on a per group level, Expansions require careful choice between scaling-out or scaling-up at each upgrade period. your Dell EMC XtremIO X2. But OEM support won't last forever. Dell EMC XtremIO is Dell EMC 's high-volume, high-capacity all-flash enterprise storage platform. there is no such menu option. Although XDP hasnt been redesigned, in the X2 implementation, additional drives added to a system result in multiple XDP groups being created. As ever, this is the challenge, how to remain competitive in a market that is stagnant or even shrinking. third-party data center hardware maintenance company, Converged Technology Extension for VMAX Storage 400K, VxRack System Flex with Dell 13G PowerEdge Nodes. Need to know about the end of support status for XtremIo. Height: 43.2mm (1.7") Width: 438mm (17.25") Depth: 756mm (29.75") Weight: 16kg (35 lbs.) As a result, dedupe still remains notably absent on VMAX All-Flash. Migration Architect. There is no need to worry, contact Top Gun today to have a free consultation about the transition from Dell support and maintenance. They have access to trusted parts that will work with your equipment. This can be a problem because the parts may not work with your equipment. United States. Dell EMC XtremIO X2-R End of Life/End of Service Life Date | EOL & EOSL The XtremIO X2 storage platform is primarily designed for applications that benefit from its data reduction and copy data management capabilities. Sign up for Newsletter. . Wait for it to charge, and then finally your first storage controller should come back online. it seems this item only appears in the menu when the counter reachs the threshold.